MSDuel Critical evaluation
2 posters
Page 1 of 1
MSDuel Critical evaluation
This topic is to keep the main msduel topic clean. Here, I want people to post critical evaluations of maps for improvements. Remember, just because you suggest something doesn't mean it will be taken. But it is good to suggest anyway.
Follow format please. One map at a time. Please spoiler large walls of text.
Name
Critique
Suggestions for improvement
Follow format please. One map at a time. Please spoiler large walls of text.
Name
Critique
Suggestions for improvement
Spirit Soldier- Posts : 301
Reputation : 1
Join date : 2010-07-18
Re: MSDuel Critical evaluation
- "Advice in General":
- *Well textures need to blend. You can get away with it occasionally, but it's not right to have red bricks connected generic gray.
*Don't forget to check your map for misalignments. They're ugly and need to go away.
*For spawn points, make sure you have at least 8. In addition make sure you give the spawn multiple choices of direction. This was one of the reasons SSL2 sucked for me. You mostly spawned in a niche in the wall where you could only go forward. This involved a TON of spawn kills. It gets annoying.
*Put an SSG in the map. You don't have to listen to this but the Supershotgun is the most popular duel weapon.
*Don't make camp-killing possible. For example, there's only one SSG in a map, and if you camp near it and kill your opponent everytime he/she goes for it, what fun is that?
*Make it smooth. If you consistently bump into objects or have a hard time getting through a door, then it isn't smooth.
Well those are suggestions I hope you'll take, though I'm sure most of it has been heard before.
Anna- Posts : 44
Reputation : 0
Join date : 2010-10-26
Age : 31
Location : Something Epic
Re: MSDuel Critical evaluation
MSDuel08: MS Receiving
Critique
It's pretty big and open.
Suggestions for improvement
IMO, it desperately needs a BFG. Also, from the ground level to the balcony, possibly an elevator? That would increase playability, because the balcony as of now only has 1 access route.
Critique
It's pretty big and open.
Suggestions for improvement
IMO, it desperately needs a BFG. Also, from the ground level to the balcony, possibly an elevator? That would increase playability, because the balcony as of now only has 1 access route.
Spirit Soldier- Posts : 301
Reputation : 1
Join date : 2010-07-18
Re: MSDuel Critical evaluation
MSduel10 - The Final Frontier: Duel Version
Critique
There are some slight visual issues.
Suggestions for improvement
I'd like to point out first that from high ground the sky can be viewed as a city floating in space, so the sky should be made either completely starry sky, or a skybox should be made. Secondly there are some small texture issues like misalignments and unsmooth textures near the paneless windows.
Critique
There are some slight visual issues.
Suggestions for improvement
I'd like to point out first that from high ground the sky can be viewed as a city floating in space, so the sky should be made either completely starry sky, or a skybox should be made. Secondly there are some small texture issues like misalignments and unsmooth textures near the paneless windows.
Anna- Posts : 44
Reputation : 0
Join date : 2010-10-26
Age : 31
Location : Something Epic
Re: MSDuel Critical evaluation
http://www.sendspace.com/file/k3u31i
Look carefully at this map. I made changes from the version play tested to allow clearer bfg defense.
Please critically evaluate this as an msduel map. I've gotten mixed reviews thus far.
Look carefully at this map. I made changes from the version play tested to allow clearer bfg defense.
Please critically evaluate this as an msduel map. I've gotten mixed reviews thus far.
Spirit Soldier- Posts : 301
Reputation : 1
Join date : 2010-07-18
Similar topics
» MSDuel! - Released!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
» MSDuel Maps
» MSDuel - List of known bugs
» Latest MSDuel Compile
» MSDuel Maps
» MSDuel - List of known bugs
» Latest MSDuel Compile
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|